diff --git a/app/Http/Resources/TransactionResource.php b/app/Http/Resources/TransactionResource.php
index 633985cf..58175802 100644
--- a/app/Http/Resources/TransactionResource.php
+++ b/app/Http/Resources/TransactionResource.php
@@ -35,7 +35,13 @@ class TransactionResource extends JsonResource
             'status' => (int) $this->status,
             'details' => TransactionDetailResource::collection($this->transactionDetails),
             'documents' => new DocumentResource($this->documents()->first()),
-            'customer_booking' => new TransactionResource($this->when((int) $this->type === TransactionType::BILL, $this->booking->transactions()->payments()->complete()->where('original_amount', '=', $this->original_amount)->where('id', '<', $this->id)->orderByDesc('id')->first())),
+            'customer_booking' => new TransactionResource($this->when((int) $this->type === TransactionType::BILL, function(){
+                $key = 0;
+                $bills = $this->booking->transactions()->bills()->where('original_amount', '=', $this->original_amount)->get();
+                if(count($bills) > 1){ $key = $bills->search(function($bill){ return $bill->id === $this->id; }); }
+                return $this->booking->transactions()->payments()->complete()->where('original_amount', '=', $this->original_amount)->skip($key)->first();
+
+            })),
             'expires_on' => Carbon::parse($this->expires_on)->format('d-m-Y h:i:s A'),
             'updated_at' => Carbon::parse($this->updated_at)->format('d-m-Y h:i:s A')
         ];