diff --git a/app/Classes/Modules/Companies/ControllersLogic/BulkDownloadCustomerInvoicesLogic.php b/app/Classes/Modules/Companies/ControllersLogic/BulkDownloadCustomerInvoicesLogic.php
index b6279192..a02ff4e8 100644
--- a/app/Classes/Modules/Companies/ControllersLogic/BulkDownloadCustomerInvoicesLogic.php
+++ b/app/Classes/Modules/Companies/ControllersLogic/BulkDownloadCustomerInvoicesLogic.php
@@ -65,8 +65,8 @@ class BulkDownloadCustomerInvoicesLogic
 
                 $zipFileName = "invoices_{$startDate}_to_{$endDate}_{$company->reference}.zip";
                 $zip_file = "{$zipDirectory}/{$zipFileName}";
-                $zipFileName2 = "invoices_{$startDate}_to_{$endDate}_{$company->reference}_dup.zip";
-                $zip_file2 = "{$zipDirectory}/{$zipFileName2}";
+                // $zipFileName2 = "invoices_{$startDate}_to_{$endDate}_{$company->reference}_dup.zip";
+                // $zip_file2 = "{$zipDirectory}/{$zipFileName2}";
 
                 $zip = new ZipArchive();
                 if ($zip->open($zip_file, ZipArchive::CREATE | ZipArchive::OVERWRITE)) {
@@ -77,13 +77,13 @@ class BulkDownloadCustomerInvoicesLogic
                     }
                     $zip->close();
 
-                    $filePath = 'bulk_invoice/'.$zipFileName;
-                    Storage::put($filePath, file_get_contents($zip_file), 's3');
+                    // $filePathForS3 = 'bulk_invoice/'.$zipFileName;
+                    // Storage::put($filePathForS3, file_get_contents($zip_file), 's3');
+                    // $responseContent = Storage::disk('s3')->get($filePathForS3);
+                    // file_put_contents($zip_file2, $responseContent);
+                    // return response()->download($zip_file2);
 
-                    $responseContent = Storage::disk('s3')->get($filePath);
-                    file_put_contents($zip_file2, $responseContent);
-
-                    return response()->download($zip_file2);
+                    return response()->download($zip_file);
                 } else {
                     return response()->json([
                         'status' => 'Error',