diff --git a/routes/web.php b/routes/web.php
index 014501c7..b1e5f02b 100644
--- a/routes/web.php
+++ b/routes/web.php
@@ -874,11 +874,13 @@ Route::get('/invoices/delete-duplicated', function(Request $request){
         // check inside packingList has how many unpaid invoice
         $unpaidInvoices = $packingList->transactions()->where('type', TransactionType::SHIPPING_INVOICE)->whereIn('status', [ApprovalStatus::PENDING_SUBMISSION, ApprovalStatus::PENDING_VERIFICATION, ApprovalStatus::APPROVED])->get()->sortByDesc('created_at');
 
-        dump('unpaidInvoices' . $unpaidInvoices);
+        print_r('unpaidInvoices');
+        dump($unpaidInvoices);
         
         if (count($paidInvoice)) {
             // delete all other invoice 
-            dump('unpaidInvoices - has count paidInvoice' . $unpaidInvoices);
+            print_r('unpaidInvoices - has count paidInvoice');
+            dump($unpaidInvoices);
             // $unpaidInvoices->delete();
             continue;
         }
@@ -887,7 +889,8 @@ Route::get('/invoices/delete-duplicated', function(Request $request){
         $unpaidInvoicesIds = $unpaidInvoices->pluck('id')->toArray();
         $latestInvoiceId = array_shift($unpaidInvoicesIds);
 
-        dump('unpaidInvoicesIds' . $unpaidInvoicesIds);
+        print_r('unpaidInvoicesIds');
+        dump($unpaidInvoicesIds);
 
         // Transaction::whereIn('id', $unpaidInvoicesIds)->delete();
         // dump(Transaction::whereIn('id', $unpaidInvoicesIds)->get());