diff --git a/routes/web.php b/routes/web.php
index a2e35cf9..523b1d56 100644
--- a/routes/web.php
+++ b/routes/web.php
@@ -869,30 +869,27 @@ Route::get('/invoices/delete-duplicated', function(Request $request){
         $order = $packingList->owner;
         $order_marking = $order->reference;
 
-        // delete for order_marking 165005587 only
-        if ($order_marking == 165005587) {
-            $duplicatedShipingInvoice = $packingList->transactions->where('type', TransactionType::SHIPPING_INVOICE);
+        $paidInvoice = $packingList->transactions->where('type', TransactionType::SHIPPING_INVOICE)->where('status', ApprovalStatus::COMPLETED)->get();
 
-            if (sizeof($duplicatedShipingInvoice)) {
-                $paidShippingInvoice = $duplicatedShipingInvoice->where('status', ApprovalStatus::COMPLETED);
+        // check inside packingList has how many unpaid invoice
+        $unpaidInvoices = $packingList->transactions->where('type', TransactionType::SHIPPING_INVOICE)->whereIn('status', [ApprovalStatus::PENDING_SUBMISSION, ApprovalStatus::PENDING_VERIFICATION, ApprovalStatus::APPROVED])->sortByDesc('created_at')->get();
 
-                if (sizeof($paidShippingInvoice)) {
-                    // if packing list have any paid invoices, delete all the unpaid 
+        dump($unpaidInvoices);
         
-                    if ($invoice->id != $paidShippingInvoice->id ) {
-                        // delete this invoice
-                        $invoice->delete();
-                        dump('Deleted invoice id -' . $invoice->id);
-                    }
-                } else {
-                    // if all unpaid, leave the latest one, delete all 
-                    if ($invoice->id != $duplicatedShipingInvoice->sortByDesc('created_at')->first()->id ) {
-                        // delete this invoice
-                        $invoice->delete();
-                        dump('Deleted invoice id -' . $invoice->id);
-                    }
-                }
-            }
+        if (count($paidInvoice)) {
+            // delete all other invoice 
+            dump($unpaidInvoices);
+            // $unpaidInvoices->delete();
+            continue;
         }
+
+        // does not have paid invoice, then delete all but the latest
+        $unpaidInvoicesIds = $unpaidInvoices->pluck('id');
+        $latestInvoiceId = array_shift($unpaidInvoicesIds);
+
+        dump($unpaidInvoicesIds);
+
+        // Transaction::whereIn('id', $unpaidInvoicesIds)->delete();
+        // dump(Transaction::whereIn('id', $unpaidInvoicesIds)->get());
     }
 }); 
\ No newline at end of file